GemNews

All stories · Case study

Plain-text founder emails report 1.8–2.7% placed order rates, vs. 0.3% for branded HTML emails

A thank-you email from the founder, sent immediately after a customer places an order, reportedly generates a 1.8–2.7% placed order rate. A branded, design-heavy version generates just 0.3%, according to ecommerce email marketer Max Sturtevant.

By Janie Nguyen · · 10 min read

Share: WhatsApp · Telegram · X · Facebook · LinkedIn · Email

That is a striking difference. But it needs context: these are self-reported attribution figures, not independently verified incremental sales.

For Shopify merchants using Klaviyo, the idea is worth testing before Black Friday Cyber Monday (BFCM). The setup is simple: put a personal, plain-text email at the beginning of your post-purchase flow, remove unnecessary delays, and make sure Smart Sending does not suppress it.

What you need before getting started

Before building the flow, make sure you have:

  • A Shopify store connected to Klaviyo.
  • An active post-purchase flow or the ability to create one.
  • A monitored founder or customer support inbox so customers can reply directly.
  • A clear distinction between your marketing thank-you email and your transactional order confirmation.

The goal is not to replace the order confirmation. It is to add a personal message that makes the customer feel acknowledged after buying.

Build a post-purchase flow that sends immediately

Klaviyo recommends using the Placed Order event as the trigger for a post-purchase flow. It also explicitly advises against adding a time delay before the first message in a thank-you flow.

Here is how to set it up:

1. Create a new flow.

Go to Flows → Create Flow → Build Your Own. Give the flow a name that makes its purpose clear, such as "Founder Thank-You."

2. Choose Placed Order as the trigger.

Select Placed Order from the trigger menu. This means the flow starts when a customer completes a purchase in your Shopify store.

3. Remove the initial time delay.

Place your thank-you email directly after the trigger. Do not add a one-day or several-hour delay before this first message.

4. Segment first-time and returning customers.

Use a conditional split based on order history. Klaviyo's guide suggests checking whether Placed Order equals 1 over all time to identify first-time customers.

This gives you room to personalize the message without making every customer receive the same introduction.

5. Check other order-related messages.

Review your fulfillment and shipping flows to avoid sending several messages at once. The founder email should arrive promptly without creating unnecessary inbox noise.

6. Set the flow to Live.

Review the configuration, test the email, and switch the flow status to Live when everything is ready.

Official setup guide: How to create a post-purchase flow - Klaviyo.

Write it like a founder, not a marketing department

The strength of this email is its personal tone, not its design.

The format described by Max Sturtevant and independently echoed in a LinkedIn post by Philip Moldovanu follows a simple structure:

  • A genuine thank-you: Acknowledge the customer's purchase.
  • A founder's story: Briefly explain why you started the business or what the brand stands for.
  • An open invitation: Encourage customers to reply if they have questions or need help.
  • A subtle next step: Include one small link to explore another product or shop again, if appropriate.

Keep the email short. Use the founder's name as the sender, write in the first person, and avoid promotional language that makes the message feel like another campaign.

Klaviyo supports a Text only email format, which is designed to feel more personal than a heavily designed email.

Source: How to create flow email content - Klaviyo.

The hidden problem: Smart Sending can stop the email from arriving

An immediate trigger does not guarantee immediate delivery.

Klaviyo's default email Smart Sending window is 16 hours. When Smart Sending is enabled, a marketing email can be skipped if the recipient has received another email within that period.

That matters during BFCM. A customer might purchase after clicking a promotional campaign or abandoned-cart email. If the founder thank-you message has Smart Sending enabled, it may be skipped.

And a skipped message is not automatically sent again when the window expires.

How to prevent this:

  1. Open the founder thank-you email inside your flow.
  2. Find the Settings section.
  3. Locate Skip recently emailed profiles.
  4. Clear the checkbox to turn off Smart Sending for this specific email.
  5. Save your changes.

Do not disable Smart Sending across your entire account. Keep it enabled for other marketing messages where frequency control matters.

One important distinction: Klaviyo's Smart Sending does not skip transactional emails, such as order confirmations. This guide concerns a marketing thank-you message, not the transactional confirmation.

Sources: Understanding Smart Sending · Reviewing flow email settings.

What does 1.8–2.7% actually measure?

This is where the headline needs a closer look.

Sturtevant reports a 1.8–2.7% placed order rate for the plain-text founder email, compared with 0.3% for a designed post-purchase email.

But a placed order rate is not necessarily proof that an email generated additional purchases.

According to Klaviyo's analytics glossary, the metric measures the number of unique recipients whose orders are attributed to a message within its attribution window, divided by the number of delivered messages.

Klaviyo's default attribution model for new accounts is last touch. Its default email lookback windows are five days for opens and five days for clicks.

In practical terms, a customer who opens the thank-you email and places another order within the attribution window may have that order credited to the email.

That does not establish that the email caused the purchase. The customer might already have intended to buy again, or another marketing interaction might have influenced the decision.

There is another limitation: the original post does not disclose the number of stores, sample size, measurement period, attribution platform, or experimental controls.

Treat 1.8–2.7% as a result worth investigating, not an industry benchmark.

Test it in your own store

Rather than adopting the reported numbers as a target, compare the two email formats in your own post-purchase flow.

Klaviyo supports A/B testing individual flow emails, including plain-text versus image-heavy HTML versions.

A practical test:

Variation AVariation B
Plain-text founder emailBranded, designed email
Personal first-person messageExisting brand template
Minimal formattingVisual elements and branded layout

Keep the audience, trigger, timing, offer, and measurement window consistent. Change the email format and content rather than several variables at once.

Measure:

  • Placed order rate: Which version receives more attributed repeat orders?
  • Revenue per recipient: Which version receives more attributed revenue per delivered email?
  • Click rate: Are customers engaging with the next-step link?
  • Unsubscribe and complaint rates: Does the message create unwanted inbox pressure?

Klaviyo can automatically identify a winning variation after statistical significance is reached, depending on your test configuration.

Source: How to A/B test a flow email - Klaviyo.

One final distinction matters: an A/B test tells you which email performs better. It does not necessarily prove that sending a thank-you email generates more sales than sending no email at all. To measure incremental impact, you would need a properly designed holdout group.

The takeaway

A founder thank-you email is a relatively low-effort experiment ahead of BFCM. It can make the post-purchase experience feel more personal without requiring another ad campaign or a complicated creative production process.

But the opportunity is not simply to chase a 1.8–2.7% figure.

Build the email at the beginning of your Placed Order flow. Remove the initial delay. Check the message-level Smart Sending setting. Then test plain text against your existing branded email.

The real question is not whether another store can report a higher attribution rate. It is whether the founder email can produce more repeat purchases in your store.


Sources · 8 · x.com, linkedin.com, help.klaviyo.com

Ask AI next

  1. How do I set up a Klaviyo holdout group to measure this founder email's true incremental lift?
  2. How should a founder keep replies feeling personal once order volume spikes during BFCM and the inbox gets flooded?
  3. Do other ESPs like Omnisend or Postscript offer the same Smart Sending-style control for post-purchase flow emails?
  4. How common is this founder thank-you email tactic among Shopify or D2C brands right now?
  5. What signs would indicate this founder-email tactic is losing effectiveness as more brands start copying it?

Discuss on GemCommunity