GemNews

All stories · Hot News

Shopify tightens app submission limits for app builders

A Shopify developer had a public app installed on three active stores. Yet when the team tried to submit its next app, the Partner Dashboard returned a “Submission limited” error.

By Janie Nguyen · · 9 min read

Share: WhatsApp · Telegram · X · Facebook · LinkedIn · Email

The reason is a new set of submission limits documented by Shopify. Having an existing app with paying merchants is no longer enough. Before submitting another new app, an organization must meet two conditions: no other new app can be under review, and every published app must have at least 10 paid installs.

For small agencies and independent developers, the second condition could become the bigger obstacle.

Two conditions. Both must be met.

According to Shopify's official Submit your app for review documentation, organizations must satisfy both requirements before submitting a new app.

Only one new app can be under review at a time.

An app counts toward this limit from submission until publication. This includes apps waiting for a reviewer and apps waiting for developers to address review feedback.

Every published app must have at least 10 paid installs.

The threshold applies to each published app individually, not the organization's combined install count.

Only installs from active stores on paid Shopify plans count. Development stores and stores on free trials are excluded.

Shopify also notes that install counts update once a day, so a new install might take up to 24 hours to appear.

Source: Shopify - Submit your app for review

Existing apps can still ship updates

The new limits apply specifically to apps that have never been published, including apps that developers previously withdrew and are submitting again.

They do not apply to:

  • Updates to apps that are already published.
  • Resubmissions of apps already in the review process after developers address feedback.

There is also an important distinction around cooldowns.

An app in a cooldown period does not count toward the one-app-under-review limit. However, that app itself cannot be resubmitted until the cooldown ends. Once it does, the new-app submission limits apply again if it has never been published.

In other words, Shopify is restricting the pipeline for launching new apps, not the ability to maintain existing ones.

Developers can continue shipping features and improvements to their published apps while waiting for their next new app submission.

Source: Shopify - Submit your app for review

Who gets stuck waiting the longest?

The rule may affect developers differently depending on how they acquire customers.

Niche B2B apps with long sales cycles

In a November 7 discussion on the Shopify Developer Community, developer Jeremy_R pointed out that selling expensive B2B software can take months.

Requiring 10 paid installs before launching another app could put independent developers and niche B2B products at a disadvantage, even when their existing products are fully developed and serving real customers.

Agencies building public unlisted apps for clients

Another developer, soulchild, raised a different concern in a November 6 forum discussion.

Some agencies build public apps with limited visibility for existing clients. These apps still go through Shopify's review process, but they are not designed to attract customers through App Store discovery.

A client might have several Shopify stores without being on Shopify Plus. Building and maintaining a separate custom app for every store can be time-consuming and complicated, making a public unlisted app a more practical solution.

The problem is that such apps may never reach 10 paid installs.

Shopify's documentation confirms that public apps with limited visibility go through the same review requirements as fully visible apps. However, its new submission limits page does not explicitly clarify whether limited-visibility published apps are exempt from the 10-install threshold.

That is an important distinction the developer community is asking Shopify to address.

Additional Shopify documentation: App listing visibility

Seeing "Submission limited"? Check these things first.

If your organization is blocked from submitting a new app, start with the Partner Dashboard.

  • Check every published app individually. Make sure each has at least 10 installs from active stores on paid plans.
  • Exclude development and free-trial stores. They do not contribute toward the threshold.
  • Check your review queue. Another new app waiting for review or waiting for you to address feedback can block the next submission.
  • Check whether an app is in cooldown. A cooldown removes that app from the one-app review limit, but you still cannot resubmit it until the specified date.
  • Allow for the daily install-count update. A newly acquired paid install may take up to a day to register.

If another new app is holding up the queue, Shopify says you can submit the next one once the existing app is published or enters cooldown. You can also withdraw or delete it in eligible circumstances. Withdrawal is only available while an app is waiting for a reviewer, not when feedback needs to be addressed or the app has been rejected.

Shopify's own recommendation is straightforward: submit your most complete app first. Run the automated checks and make sure the app meets the requirements before sending it for review.

Repeated review problems can also lead to cooldowns, with each additional cooldown lasting longer than the previous one.

Source: Shopify - Submission limits and app submission paused

Another gate the developer community had already discussed

The new rule has also brought attention to an earlier proposal from developer @kylebigley on X.

His proposal suggested setting a higher bar before an app becomes publicly visible: at least 10 store installs, three reviews and $100 in revenue.

The distinction is where the gate is placed.

  • The proposal: Restrict an app's visibility until it demonstrates some market traction.
  • Shopify's new rule: Restrict an organization's ability to submit its next new app until every published app reaches the paid-install threshold.

One controls when an app gets broader exposure. The other controls when developers can launch their next product.

The two approaches share an emphasis on market validation, but they are not the same policy. The X post is a developer's proposal, not an explanation of Shopify's decision.

The discussion has also prompted questions about whether the new rules make the App Store healthier or create more barriers for independent developers. A separate LinkedIn discussion by @samsal-islam raised that broader concern.

What should developers do next?

Before scheduling another app launch, open your Partner Dashboard and count the paid installs for every published app under your organization.

Then review your submission queue and decide which app is the most complete and ready to pass review.

For agencies working with public unlisted apps, there is one unresolved issue worth raising directly with Shopify:

Should public unlisted apps built for existing clients be subject to the same 10-paid-install threshold as fully visible App Store apps?

Have you already encountered the "Submission limited" status? Are you changing the order in which you submit new apps because of this rule?

Share your experience in the comments. We'll update this article if Shopify provides further clarification.

Sources · 6 · shopify.dev, community.shopify.dev, x.com +1

Ask AI next

  1. If a paid install downgrades to a free plan later, does it get subtracted from an app's 10-install count?
  2. How long does each escalating Shopify app-review cooldown period actually last?
  3. What tools can track Shopify Partner app install counts and cooldown dates automatically?
  4. Do other app marketplaces enforce similar paid-install thresholds before allowing new app submissions?
  5. Has Shopify responded yet to requests to exempt public unlisted apps from the 10-install rule?

Discuss on GemCommunity